To table NPRR287 and to request that the Nodal Advisory Task Force (NATF) work with ERCOT Staff toward a better solution.
Vote tallies here reflect individual votes, not the weight of the votes by market segment.
Affirmative votes are not recorded in these vote tallies. For additional details on the voting
record, please consult the Recommendation or Action Report, or the official vote tally if
available, as posted in the key documents.
Oct 18, 2010
This Nodal Protocol Revision Request (NPRR) proposes to remove Locational Marginal Prices (LMPs) from Inter-Control Center Communications Protocol (ICCP) communications, based on emerging concerns regarding the inconsistent timeframes for price delivery in Real-Time.
Based on ERCOT’s analysis, there is not a methodology by which the delivery of Real-Time prices can be "synchronously" delivered at the same time across the two different existing technologies (ICCP and webservices). In addition, ERCOT cannot guarantee any technology solution that is faster than ICCP prior to Nodal go-live for delivery of pricing data.
Although there have been historical discussions about whether ICCP should be expanded to pump prices faster to the broader ERCOT market (beyond Qualified Scheduling Entities (QSEs) with Resources), issues that have prevented further consideration in the past are:
(1) The risk to performance of the Real-Time command and control instructions; and
(2) The cost of additional telemetry bandwidth and support.
For further consideration, it is worth noting that a recent samplings of delivery across the two technologies was:
- ICCP: a range of 4-8 seconds; and
- Webservices report: a range of 4-13 seconds, with an average of 6 seconds (MP would still need to retrieve report).
ERCOT is pursuing technical options to possibly increase the webservices delivery speed and create an end-user table display that may bring the timeline even closer to ICCP delivery, but it would not be synchronous and cannot be guaranteed to be faster.
If, based on this analysis of the different timing of price delivery, this is a significant market issue, ERCOT would propose that ICCP be limited to exclude all prices, which results in changes to the table summary in Section 6.3.2 but does not change the elements supported in Section 18.104.22.168, Base Points. In this manner the delivery of prices to all ERCOT Market Participants are on the same timeline, where the Market Participant can leverage existing web services or displays to monitor and act on changes in prices that are posted upon completion of every Security-Constrained Economic Dispatch (SCED) run to the Market Information System (MIS) Public Area.
It is also noted that upon approval of this NPRR it would require removal of price fields from the ICCP Handbook (Table 20). This systematic removal is a quick change for ERCOT systems (configuration change), but may be a significant change to QSEs that have built pricing logic into their telemetry and downstream business processes.